# Heinen to defend tax plan in Senate despite VVD opposition

> The finance minister will argue for the tax plan in the Eerste Kamer, the upper house, although his own VVD voted against it in the lower house.

Politics · published 2026-11-20 12:32 · updated 2026-11-21 06:26 · https://nlnow.nl/a/heinen-to-defend-tax-plan-in-senate-despite-vvd-opposition/

Finance Minister Eelco Heinen (VVD) will defend the government's tax plan in the Eerste Kamer, the Senate, even though his own party voted against it in the Tweede Kamer. Heinen said so before the cabinet meeting.

He will do it as a "a servant of the Crown" (dienaar van de Kroon). In practice that means a minister presents and argues for the government's proposal in parliament, whatever his own party did in the vote.

> This tax plan is not social and offers no progress. Now parties from left to right are defending the decline of workers and people who need care. Choose progress:
> — Jimmy Dijk, SP parliamentary leader, on X (https://x.com/jimmydijk/status/2123447390279540902) (translated from Dutch)

The VVD voted against after coalition partners D66 and CDA helped a proposal by PRO and Volt win a majority. That proposal shifts a small part of the tax burden from labour to capital.

The plan still passed the lower house. A number of smaller parties backed it, which carried it through despite the liberals' vote against. The Senate is now the next step for the plan.

The cabinet governs without a majority of its own in parliament. D66 and CDA are the VVD's coalition partners, so their decision to back the PRO and Volt proposal put the finance minister in the position of defending a plan his own party rejected.

Heinen said it is his task to gather support in both chambers for the cabinet's plans. "And I'll do that until my dying breath," he said. He declined to comment on how his party voted. "That judgement is for the parliamentary group," he said.

The VVD group in the Senate said this week that it will vote for the tax plan. Heinen also stressed that the Tweede Kamer has the right to amend bills. State Secretary for Taxation Eelco Eerenberg (D66) called the plan the "artery" of central government.

## Background

- **Eerste Kamer**: The Senate, the upper house of the Dutch parliament. It cannot amend bills but can approve or reject them after the Tweede Kamer has passed them. Its 75 members are elected by the members of the provincial councils.
- **Tweede Kamer**: The House of Representatives, the lower and more powerful house of the Dutch parliament. Its 150 members are elected directly; it can amend bills and holds the cabinet to account.
- **PRO**: PRO is a Dutch political party with seats in the Tweede Kamer, the House of Representatives, where it introduces and votes on motions and proposals. In this context, it is the party that submitted, together with Volt, a proposal to shift a small part of the tax burden from labour to capital, which won a majority in the House.

From NLnow, news from the Netherlands in English. How stories are made: https://nlnow.nl/about/
