# Cabinet advises against €1bn tax shift backed by D66 and CDA

> The cabinet says the PRO and Volt amendment to the tax plan is not fully paid for, and the VVD says it will vote against the whole plan if the amendment passes in Thursday's debate.

Politics · published 2026-11-12 16:32 · https://nlnow.nl/a/cabinet-advises-against-1bn-tax-shift-backed-by-d66-and-cda/

The Tweede Kamer debates the Belastingplan (tax plan) on Thursday, a day after coalition parties D66 and CDA struck a deal with PRO and Volt. The parties' amendment shifts €1bn in tax from labour to wealth, and the cabinet advises against it.

In a written response made public on Thursday afternoon, the cabinet says the cost is insufficiently covered. The four parties are €404m short, it says, because the funding is not fully arranged. One idea is an exit tax (exit-heffing) on wealthy people: those who leave the Netherlands would pay tax on the wealth they take abroad.

> PVV motion of no confidence rejected. Will the VVD pull the plug on the cabinet themselves now that the tax plan including millionaire's tax has been adopted or are they too cowardly for that? #DEBAT
> — Geert Wilders, on X (https://x.com/geertwilderspvv/status/2120976267482640758) (translated from Dutch)

Under the proposal, people in box 3 who make more than €60,000 in returns on their wealth in one year would be taxed more heavily. That revenue helps pay for a lower first income tax rate. The cabinet adds that the amendment may cause implementation problems for the Belastingdienst.

> The SGP does not want to be jointly responsible for a substantively bad tax plan that does not address the huge tax gap between single-earner and dual-earner households, saddles families with higher tax burdens, and brands savers and entrepreneurs as millionaires. Moreover, by providing support we would also keep in place a cabinet that encourages hospitals to roll out the trial with late abortions nationwide, wants to further legalise surrogacy, wants to force municipalities to create extra AZC’s, and wants to make practically one-third of all our farmers stop. That is why we voted against the tax plan this evening with great conviction.
> — SGP, SGP, on X (https://x.com/SGPnieuws/status/2120988667980484899) (translated from Dutch)

If parliament backs an amendment the cabinet advises against, the cabinet does not have to carry it out. It does risk a motion of no confidence by doing so.

> A lot of big words are being used today about the PRO & Volt millionaire tax. That's why it's good to look at who exactly will pay with this new top rate (& lowering of the normal rate) in box 3. The proceeds from this go to lower taxes for working people!
> — Tom van der Lee, PRO MP, on X (https://x.com/TomvanderLee/status/2120889554517282950) (translated from Dutch)

VVD parliamentary leader Ruben Brekelmans made clear his party will vote against the Belastingplan if the amendment is adopted. He says a fundamental reset is needed "sowieso" (in any case), repeating what VVD leader Dilan Yeşilgöz said. She said on Wednesday that a restart is only needed if D66 and CDA vote for the amendment on Thursday.

The two VVD leaders also differ on how the deal reached them. Yeşilgöz said the party was informed only when media were already reporting on it. Brekelmans says the VVD was told an hour beforehand.

## Background

- **Tweede Kamer**: The House of Representatives, the lower and more powerful house of the Dutch parliament. Its 150 members are elected directly; it can amend bills and holds the cabinet to account.
- **Box 3**: The part of Dutch income tax that taxes savings and investments. Tax is charged on an assumed return rather than the actual return; after the Supreme Court ruled from 2021 that this can breach property rights, the system has to be reformed.
- **PRO**: PRO is a political party represented in the Tweede Kamer, the lower house of the Dutch parliament. It is not one of the coalition parties, so when it supports or opposes a proposal, its votes count alongside those of other parliamentary groups.
- **Belastingdienst**: The Dutch Tax and Customs Administration is the government agency, part of the Ministry of Finance, that collects taxes and handles customs duties in the Netherlands. It also processes tax returns and applies the rules for taxes such as income tax and box 3 wealth tax. Any change to tax rules has to be workable for it, which is why it is consulted on how new measures would be carried out.

From NLnow, news from the Netherlands in English. How stories are made: https://nlnow.nl/about/
