# Advisory council fears Netherlands is becoming hard to govern

> The Raad voor het Openbaar Bestuur, which advises government and parliament, says the crisis over the tax plan pushes good governance past its limits and risks real harm to society.

Politics · published 2026-11-16 13:47 · https://nlnow.nl/a/advisory-body-warns-cabinet-crisis-is-damaging-dutch-governability/

An independent advisory body says it is seriously concerned about whether the Netherlands can be governed. The Raad voor het Openbaar Bestuur (ROB) says in a position paper published on Sunday that the limits of good governance are being exceeded so far "that society seems to be suffering great damage". The council says it normally stays out of current events but is making an exception because of the cabinet crisis over the Belastingplan, the annual tax package.

The crisis comes nine months after the cabinet took office. The Belastingplan passed the Tweede Kamer by a narrow majority of 76 members. VVD, PVV, JA21, FVD, Groep Markuszower, BBB, SGP, SP and Keijzer voted against. The council says that rejecting a Belastingplan, as those parties tried to do, means billions in intended revenue are not collected and adds to uncertainty for citizens and businesses.

> This tax plan, including amendments, is worse for working people and people who need care. Deterioration compared to the previous tax plan: - higher income tax: 6.5 billion - higher health insurance premium (€170) - higher deductible (€400) - "Vrijheidsbijdrage"/"bommenbelasting" (bomb tax): 1.7 billion - abolishing deductible healthcare costs: incl. bridges, crowns, prostheses, insoles and pacemakers. This is not a social or "left" tax plan.
> — Jimmy Dijk, SP parliamentary leader, on X (https://x.com/jimmydijk/status/2122057539525173735) (translated from Dutch)

The council says politics in The Hague is "almost more occupied with forming cabinets than with governing". In the past decade the Netherlands has had a caretaker cabinet for almost a third of the time, it notes.

> With every previous post you think, it's impossible for it to get any worse. But it can actually get worse than it already was 👇 ministerLJS what are we doing?!
> — Nicole Moinat, Groep Markuszower MP, on X (https://x.com/NicoleMoinat/status/2122245409381003380) (translated from Dutch)

The change of political culture that a minority cabinet needs, and that was promised, has not happened, the council says. Parties and politicians, cabinet members included, are almost permanently "in campaign mode". It also says politicians increasingly present themselves as "representatives of separate self-interests, without weighing up the interests of all citizens".

The council advises parliament that if the cabinet falls, it should form a new coalition with the current Tweede Kamer. A recent motion from the ChristenUnie calling for this was adopted by a majority.

## Background

- **Tweede Kamer**: The House of Representatives, the lower and more powerful house of the Dutch parliament. Its 150 members are elected directly; it can amend bills and holds the cabinet to account.
- **ROB (Raad voor het Openbaar Bestuur)**: The Dutch Public Administration Council is an independent advisory body that advises the government and parliament on public administration, meaning how the state is organised and how well it functions. It publishes position papers and advice on the limits and quality of good governance, and it is independent of the cabinet.
- **Belastingplan**: The Belastingplan is the annual tax bill, a package of legislation that sets tax rates and tax measures for the coming year. The cabinet submits it to the Tweede Kamer on Prinsjesdag (the third Tuesday of September), and it must be approved by parliament before it takes effect.
- **ChristenUnie**: The ChristenUnie is a Christian political party represented in the Tweede Kamer, the lower house of the Dutch parliament. Like other parliamentary parties, it proposes bills and motions and votes on the proposals of other parties, and its motions can be adopted by a majority in the Tweede Kamer.

From NLnow, news from the Netherlands in English. How stories are made: https://nlnow.nl/about/
